Commentary

'VeggieTales' Creator Gets Owned After Going Woke and Claiming God Is Nonbinary

For three decades, Phil Vischer has asked us to believe that a cucumber with no arms, no legs, and no pants is a man. Now he argues that the God of the universe — who identifies as “He,” is addressed as “He,” and became incarnate as a male — isn’t truly masculine.

On Nov. 6, Vischer, the creator of the Christian kids’ television show “VeggieTales,” entered the “God is nonbinary” argument on X.

In response to a post quoting the statement that “God is not non-binary,” Vischer wrote, “‘God is a biological male’ is a weird hill to die on.”

Post on X

@TylerHuckabee “God is a biological male” is a weird hill to die on.

— Phil Vischer (@philvischer) November 6, 2026

Then came the replies. Perhaps my favorite:

Post on X

@philvischer @TylerHuckabee God the Son literally died on a hill as a biological male in obedience to God the Father.

— Julie_married_to_Thomas_but_not_a_Thomist (@gmk_julie) November 7, 2026

The digital war raged for days as Vischer defended the view that God is genderless, while his more conservative counterparts communicated a view of God’s nature as masculine.

Those who supported the idea of a genderless God cited the spirituality of God’s nature as evidence that biological labels such as “male” or “female” can’t possibly accurately describe the Lord.

They also quoted passages like Isaiah 66:13, which describe God in maternal ways, suggesting that the plurality of gendered experience can be found within the divine.

Conversely, the conservative critics pointed to the pervasive usage of masculine pronouns and titles, and the brute fact of the incarnation as evidence of a male God. Their argument was simple: Jesus Christ is a male. Jesus Christ is God. God, therefore, is male.

The Council of Chalcedon in 451 approved such language as “God was born.” Peter says in Acts 3:15, “You killed the Author of life.” What, then, is preventing a Christian from saying “God is male”?

The incarnation, however, only explains the Son’s maleness. Why is the first Person of the Trinity called Father? Is it a purely arbitrary choice (voluntarism), or is there something about God’s divine nature that suggests a masculine representation (fittingness)?

While classical theology rightly maintains that God is pure spirit transcending biological sex, Scripture insists that the masculine analogy is not arbitrary. Ephesians 3:14–15 teaches us that God isn’t mimicking our attempts at fatherhood, but that we are mimicking His.

Related:
Watch: Baby Saved from Planned Parenthood After Sidewalk Counselor Convinces Father to Intervene

“For this reason I bow my knees before the Father, from whom every family in heaven and on earth is named,” Paul writes to the Ephesians. The word for family (patria) literally means “descended from a common father.”

Our fathers and families are modeled off the divine Father. The idea of “Fatherhood” wasn’t a mantle that God put on to connect with us. It’s a duty that He shares with billions of men worldwide.

Member poll
How should Christians understand masculine language for God?
9 votes cast

The progressive might still argue that this title of “Father” is a purely functional identity — not an ontological one. If we were talking about a normal, human father, this could be argued.

God, however, has no parts and no unrealized potential. He is what He does. He does what He is.

The first Person of the Trinity does not merely play a father’s role: He eternally begets the Son, and His identity is that of begetter. The second Person of the Trinity is eternally begotten, and therefore His identity is that of begotten.

God’s masculine identity is not the result of a coin toss, but is an eternal reflection of His initiating, covenantal role as Father.

Finally: Vischer has refused to back down and released his final word on Nov. 10, where he denounced the usage of the term “nonbinary” to describe God, admitted to using masculine terms for God, but never acknowledged that God has an intrinsically masculine nature.

Choose The Western Journal as your preferred source on Google and never miss reporting that defends truth, protects freedom, and advances Western civilization

Advertise with The Western Journal and reach millions of highly engaged readers, while supporting our work. Advertise Today.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →



We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

Samuel Proctor is a first year student at Iowa State University, studying political science and writing for the Iowa State Daily. His specialization in political theory and philosophy led him to join The Western Journal in 2026. When not writing, Samuel can be found playing guitar and praising Jesus.




Tags:
, , , ,

Conversation